Why Topics Are A Terrible Way To Organise Your Notes (& What To Do Instead)

Ev Chapman
December 23, 2024

Let's be honest - we've all been guilty of creating those perfectly labeled topic folders that turn into digital graveyards for our notes ⚡️

The problem with topics is that they are inherently passive. They don't actually mean anything to us unless we are actively pursuing something specific. And let's be real - how often do you wake up thinking "I must explore my productivity folder today!"

Instead of topics, I organise my knowledge into what I call collections.

Think of collections like Spotify playlists (or if you're old enough to remember curating mix tapes/cd's for your friends/crush).

I am one of those people who takes great joy in lovingly curating a perfect playlist for different events. Just last week I created one for Christmas dinner with friends. But I also curate playlists for any type of mood or moment:

  • Songs for sitting in a dark room with a glass of red wine 🍷
  • Songs for the 3pm pick-me-up ⚡️
  • Songs for lazy Sunday mornings
  • Songs that make me smile

Each playlist has a vibe, a purpose. And that's exactly how I think about organising my knowledge too.

Rather than a generic "Productivity" topic, I have collections like "Productivity for Human Beings Not Robots" or "The Mindsets of a 'Pro' Creator". Some are questions I'm exploring like "Is technology making us numb?"

See the difference? One is just a filing cabinet. The other primes your brain to collect & connect knowledge in service of an opinion or idea.

(It's like that scene in the movie Focus where Will Smith primes the billionaire to pick jersey number 55 by showing him the number everywhere. Your collections prime your brain to spot relevant insights everywhere).

So What Exactly Are Collections?

Collections are active containers for your knowledge.

With collections, everything you capture has a purpose. It's either helping you answer a question, shape a belief, build a concept or solve a real challenge you're facing right now.

Rather than just being a place to file things away, they help you think, explore & take action.

Collections are alive & dynamic. They help you focus your attention (just like crafting the perfect playlist), and they grow & evolve with you.

Here are 6 types of collections I keep in my knowledge library that are better than filling by topic:

1. Concepts

Whether it's a concept you're trying to understand or one you're building - these make powerful collections.

Maybe you're trying to understand Bull & Bear Markets or the 12 principles of Permaculture. These make excellent collections while you're studying something specific.

I've built some of my biggest ideas this way including The LifeLog Method & The Spark Method.

Having a container where you can spread things out, explore and build your own knowledge of the concept is absolutely vital to understanding things deeply.

2. Questions

Questions keep us curious - and isn't that the best way to build knowledge? The brilliant thing about using questions as collections is that our minds are wired to close loops.

Once you open a question, your brain naturally starts hunting for answers everywhere.

Some of the current questions in my knowledge library are:

  • Is technology making us numb?
  • What does AI mean for us: Mentally, Morally, Practically?
  • Is handwriting really better than typing (or is it just what we've always known)?

If you want to get better at exploring questions like these & thinking deeper about your ideas, you might want to check out my AI-Powered Note-Taker's Playbook that helps you supercharge your thinking and uncover angles & insights you might have regularly missed.

3. Beliefs

I strongly believe (see what I did there?) that everyone should have strongly held beliefs. But you can't have strongly held beliefs without exploring & thinking deeply about what they are.

Whenever I have a new opinion brewing, I set it up as a collection & start exploring. Some of my strongly held beliefs that have been building over the last few years are:

  • Why Inbox Zero is a terrible way to live our lives in a world of information overload.
  • Human nature is a feature not a bug and why you should follow your natural inclinations
  • Paddle Rivers, Don't Climb Mountains or how to find the easy path through life.

I never held strong beliefs or didn't know how to articulate them until I started building knowledge collections around them. Now I could confidently argue any of these positions because I have explored them in so much depth.

4. Lists

Sometimes all you need is a good list. But I'm not talking about your average grocery list here - these are dynamic collections that grow & evolve as you learn.

I keep collections like:

  • Things I'm learning about myself (this is gold for personal growth - every time I have an insight about my working style or habits, it goes straight in)
  • The Mindsets of a 'Pro' Creator (a running collection of mindset shifts I've noticed in successful creators)
  • Helpful Mental Models (because let's be real, sometimes the best way to solve a problem is to look at it differently)

Lists become these wonderful catch-alls for patterns you notice, lessons you learn & ideas you want to remember.

5. Projects

Projects are one of my favourite types of collections because they're current & actionable. But here's what makes them different from your average project folder - they're not just about tasks & deadlines. These collections become the thinking space behind your projects.

I use project collections for:

  • Actionable projects (like courses or workshops I'm building)
  • Knowledge projects (deep dives into things I want to master)
  • Personal projects (like building new habits or skills)

The beauty of project collections is that they keep everything in context. Instead of having related notes scattered across different topic folders, everything lives where you need it, when you need it.

For example, right now I'm building a new course. The collection includes everything from student messages that inspired certain modules, to random ideas that hit me in the shower, to frameworks I've been testing.

It's messy, it's organic, but everything is where I need it to be.

6. Challenges/Bottlenecks

Whenever I hit a challenge in life or work, I create a collection to house all my thoughts on it. They give me a dedicated space to focus on the challenge, process my thoughts & experiment.

Instead of letting these problems bounce around in my head or scattering possible solutions across random notes, I have one active space working towards a solution.

Right now, I'm exploring collections like:

  • How to scale a creative agency team (because growing pains are real)
  • Fixing blockages in my content creation workflow
  • Building systems that don't feel like systems

And remember what I mentioned earlier about collections being a priming tool for focus?

Now you have a collection setup for your biggest challenges guess what happens - suddenly you start to see information and knowledge about that challenge EVERYWHERE. It's literally a shortcut to problem solving.

Building Collections: Bottom-Up or Top-Down?

So here is the inevitable question - should you build collections first and then collect knowledge or do collections emerge as you are building knowledge? The answer is... BOTH. Some collections emerge over time. Others are things I intentionally create.

When I'm reading & consuming information, sometimes I'll notice patterns emerging around a particular idea - that's bottoms-up.

Other times, I'll have something specific I want to explore or solve, so I'll create the collection first & then go hunting - that's top-down.

Neither way is better. They're just different paths to the same destination: knowledge that's alive, active & actually useful.

And the beauty of collections is that they don't feel like a heavy lift.

It feels completely natural to build up a bank of captures over time as I'm reading or watching content. Then one day I'll sit down, look at everything together & suddenly connections start forming. They transform from filing cabinets to thinking spaces that help your knowledge grow & evolve naturally.

The worst thing we can do with our knowledge is let it sit there gathering digital dust. That's what happens with topic folders - they become these passive storage containers that we rarely return to.

But collections? They're dynamic. They grow with us. They help us think better, create better & solve real problems.

So next time you're about to create a new topic folder, pause & ask yourself:

  • What am I trying to learn here?
  • What problem am I trying to solve?
  • What idea am I trying to build?

Then create a collection that reflects that purpose. Trust me - your future self will thank you for it ⚡️

PS. Whenever you're ready, here are three ways I can help you turn your collections into powerful thinking tools:

  1. Want to get Sparked like this each week? Sign up to my weekly newsletter - The Spark Newsletter where I share simple systems, frameworks & strategies that help you turn your knowledge into independent income.
  2. Transform your notes into real insights with The Knowledge Alchemy Course. Learn my exact process for building dynamic collections that help you think better, create better & actually use your knowledge (instead of just letting it gather digital dust) ⚡️
  3. Level up your collections with the AI-Powered Note-Taker's Playbook. A curated set of thinking prompts to help you explore ideas deeper, distill them clearer & spot connections you might have missed. Because collections should be thinking tools, not just storage spaces ⚡️

Liked thIS? Then You Might Like My SPARK Newsletter...

The Spark Newsletter:
Join 1,500+ knowledge workers building smarter personal knowledge systems.

Every Sunday I drop into your inbox with a simple creative workflow to help you think clearer & create smarter.

Or Keep Browsing More Posts Like This...

Why Topics Are A Terrible Way To Organise Your Notes (& What To Do Instead)

Think playlists, not filing cabinets. A simple way to organise your notes so they actually spark new ideas & insights ⚡️
Read post

The High School Highlighting Habit That Is Holding You Back and How to Fix It

Most of us learned how to study books & highlight in high school. And we're still doing it the same way.
Read post

How to Generate Better Ideas by Trying Less

The fastest way to solve an idea is to leave it unfinished.
Read post

Ditch Brainstorming: Here’s How to Build an Endless Idea Ecosystem Instead

Why You'll Never Run Out of Ideas Again Once You Set Up This System
Read post

Why Your Notes Aren’t Working for You (And the One Shift You Need to Make)

Traditional note-taking methods mostly feel like information storage. You spend so much time organising, categorising, and filing rather than the real work of exploring & working with ideas.
Read post